Page name: FMAC_Poll [Logged in view] [RSS]
2007-07-12 04:53:09
Last author: xido
Owner: xido
# of watchers: 5
Fans: 0
D20: 9
Bookmark and Share

Fantasy Map Art Contest

Contest Critique, Polls and Voting

- There are many polls here!!!  Vote on all of them!!!
- You can vote multiple times on every poll (except the last one: Best of Show)!!! Your name will come up on all of them except that one, but don't worry; we won't harass you for it. ;)
<Limg100*0:>- [Ocean Soul]'s entry was edited and updated to its current version, which [Dr.Mandarian] sent to me to fix. Please look over polls 2651 and 2644 again for this update. (I also removed the three separate close-ups, and substituted the one image by itself)

FMAC_Compasses - Vote for the Compass Rose Section entries!!!

FMAC_Judging - A panel of judges will award the final winners of three categories:
  - Traditional and Authentic
  - Creative and Aesthetic
  - Best World or Continent

2643) [Cia_mar]'s entry:
Unnamed (Administrator: [xido])

Number of voters: 16

2645) [dayah]'s entry:
D'Larame & Arden (Administrator: [xido])

Number of voters: 13

2646) [Mira Ravenheart]'s entry:
Realms of Nyan (Administrator: [xido])

Number of voters: 18

2647) [Lady of Lore]'s entry:
The Four Realms (Administrator: [xido])

Number of voters: 13

2648) [Torr-maat]'s first entry:
Zendelon (Administrator: [xido])

Number of voters: 12

2649) [Torr-maat]'s second entry:
Unnamed (Administrator: [xido])

Number of voters: 12

2650) [3.00 x 10^8 Meters/Second]'s entry:
Cajia (Administrator: [xido])

Number of voters: 11

2651) [Ocean Soul]'s entry:
Nyratar (Administrator: [xido])

Number of voters: 12

2652) [Estantia]'s entry:
the 11th clan base (Administrator: [xido])

Number of voters: 10

2653) [xido]'s first entry:
Tearra Réhm (Administrator: [xido])

Number of voters: 12

2654) [xido]'s second entries:
<img100*0:> <img100*0:>
Lands of Qor (Administrator: [xido])

Number of voters: 10

2655) [Yncke]'s entry:
Eigen and Western Zouw (Administrator: [xido])

Number of voters: 12

2644) Which is the best entry for the Fantasy Map Art Contest? (Best of Show) (Administrator: [xido])

Number of voters: 20
* a) <img0*100:>
Number of votes: 0 (0%)

* b) <img0*100:>
Number of votes: 1 (5%)

* c) <img0*100:>
Number of votes: 11 (55%)

* d) <img0*100:>
Number of votes: 1 (5%)

* e) <img0*100:>
Number of votes: 2 (10%)

* f) <img0*100:>
Number of votes: 0 (0%)

* g) <img0*100:>
Number of votes: 0 (0%)

* h) <img0*100:>
Number of votes: 1 (5%)

* i) <img0*100:>
Number of votes: 0 (0%)

* j) <img0*100:>
Number of votes: 1 (5%)

* k) <img0*100:> <img0*100:>
Number of votes: 0 (0%)

* l) <img0*100:>
Number of votes: 3 (15%)

Username (or number or email):


2007-07-06 [xido]: POLLS ARE OPEN! You can vote multiple times on every poll except the Best of Show (Best Map)!

If you want to judge the final categories, see FMAC_Judging!

2007-07-11 [Ocean Soul]: A question - should you vote on your own entry? Because that doesn't seem to reasonable to me :/

2007-07-12 [xido]: As long as you are honestly evaluating your own work compared/contrasted to that of others and by the criteria posted, it is not disrespectful, and no one will be harassed in any way for voting as they wish.

FYI: I just uploaded the edited version of your map of Nyratar to polls 2651 and 2644 ( Everyone please reevaluate the map based on its current posting. (I will add a note to the top of the page about it)

Were there any other submissions made to [Dr.Mandarian] that I was unaware of? I can add them, if that is the case, and you have his permission to do so.

2007-11-19 [Dr.Mandarian]: Hey all you cartographers! I just voted for the entries for fantasy maps above - and am once more amazed again over what high level of brilliance and calibre they are. So it was kind of a hard task for me to judge them. It is a pleasure to have such manies of high quality artworks gathered here. I once again have to thank all who participated in this! And I also want to express again, in this place, how sorry I am that the whole process of the running contest has been so unfortunately interrupted for so long, due to my absence - and kind of dragged along then. I assure you that it has got nothing to do with a lack of interest in this, to any time. I just first have been forced by personal circumstances to not be able to get online for a pretty long while. And after I returned to town, I missed energy and time enough, to dedicate myself more to the outturn of the contest procedure here.
I hope that you are not badly disappointed about that.
Still I wanted to ask you all, if you'd like to finish this contest soon, yet, after all, or if you'd maybe like me to care a bit for advertising the poll more over the next days - as for example trying to apply for a main street place for it? I don't know exactly, what [xido] planned for the further scope of the contest end, but I will in any case contact him soon and discuss with him, about the evaluation of the poll above and the finish of the whole contest. Having a winner in each category and a badge for each winner then, how I hope.

2008-03-03 [xido]: Sorry I haven't checked in much. Once I got input about my own maps, I kind of stopped watching all the time.

Let me figure out how to close the polls, in case they need to be ended, which they probably should be very soon.

Show these comments on your site

Elftown - Wiki, forums, community and friendship. Sister-site to Elfwood