Wiki:
Page name: FMAC_Poll [Logged in view] [RSS]
2007-07-12 04:53:09
Last author: xido
Owner: xido
# of watchers: 5
Fans: 0
D20: 9
Bookmark and Share

Fantasy Map Art Contest

Contest Critique, Polls and Voting


Notes:
- There are many polls here!!!  Vote on all of them!!!
- You can vote multiple times on every poll (except the last one: Best of Show)!!! Your name will come up on all of them except that one, but don't worry; we won't harass you for it. ;)
<Limg100*0:http://www.elftown.com/stuff/nyratar_karte_f.jpg>- [Ocean Soul]'s entry was edited and updated to its current version, which [Dr.Mandarian] sent to me to fix. Please look over polls 2651 and 2644 again for this update. (I also removed the three separate close-ups, and substituted the one image by itself)
    






Also:
FMAC_Compasses - Vote for the Compass Rose Section entries!!!

FMAC_Judging - A panel of judges will award the final winners of three categories:
  - Traditional and Authentic
  - Creative and Aesthetic
  - Best World or Continent




2643) [Cia_mar]'s entry:
<img100*0:http://elftown.lysator.liu.se/stuff/cia%27s%20map%20wip.jpg>...
Unnamed (Administrator: [xido])

Number of voters: 16











2645) [dayah]'s entry:
<img100*0:http://elftown.lysator.liu.se/stuff/New%20map.jpg>
D'Larame & Arden (Administrator: [xido])

Number of voters: 13











2646) [Mira Ravenheart]'s entry:
<img100*0:http://elftown.lysator.liu.se/img/photo/171663_1164423286.jpg>
Realms of Nyan (Administrator: [xido])

Number of voters: 18











2647) [Lady of Lore]'s entry:
<img100*0:http://elftown.lysator.liu.se/img/drawing/60827_1169521261.jpg>
The Four Realms (Administrator: [xido])

Number of voters: 13











2648) [Torr-maat]'s first entry:
<img100*0:http://elftown.lysator.liu.se/stuff/C%3ADocuments%20and%20SettingsWillDesktopD%26DZendelon%20-%20Northern%20orientation.jpg>
Zendelon (Administrator: [xido])

Number of voters: 12











2649) [Torr-maat]'s second entry:
<img100*0:http://elftown.lysator.liu.se/img/drawing/27476_1169940846.jpg>
Unnamed (Administrator: [xido])

Number of voters: 12











2650) [3.00 x 10^8 Meters/Second]'s entry:
<img100*0:http://elftown.lysator.liu.se/img/drawing/99583_1165637041.jpg>
Cajia (Administrator: [xido])

Number of voters: 11











2651) [Ocean Soul]'s entry:
<img100*0:http://elftown.lysator.liu.se/stuff/nyratar_karte_f.jpg>
Nyratar (Administrator: [xido])

Number of voters: 12











2652) [Estantia]'s entry:
<img100*0:http://elftown.lysator.liu.se/stuff/rm11plan.png>
the 11th clan base (Administrator: [xido])

Number of voters: 10











2653) [xido]'s first entry:
<img100*0:http://elftown.lysator.liu.se/stuff/C%3ADocuments%20and%20SettingsWillDesktopD%26DTearra%20Rehm%20Web.jpg>
Tearra Réhm (Administrator: [xido])

Number of voters: 12











2654) [xido]'s second entries:
<img100*0:http://elftown.lysator.liu.se/stuff/C%3ADocuments%20and%20SettingsWillDesktopD%26DQor%20Geography%20Web.jpg> <img100*0:http://elftown.lysator.liu.se/stuff/C%3ADocuments%20and%20SettingsWillDesktopD%26DQor%20Populations.jpg>
Lands of Qor (Administrator: [xido])

Number of voters: 10











2655) [Yncke]'s entry:
<img100*0:http://elftown.lysator.liu.se/stuff/YnckesKaartVanEigen.jpg>
Eigen and Western Zouw (Administrator: [xido])

Number of voters: 12











2644) Which is the best entry for the Fantasy Map Art Contest? (Best of Show) (Administrator: [xido])

Number of voters: 20
* a) <img0*100:http://elftown.lysator.liu.se/stuff/cia%27s%20map%20wip.jpg>
Number of votes: 0 (0%)

* b) <img0*100:http://elftown.lysator.liu.se/stuff/New%20map.jpg>
Number of votes: 1 (5%)

* c) <img0*100:http://elftown.lysator.liu.se/img/photo/171663_1164423286.jpg>
Number of votes: 11 (55%)

* d) <img0*100:http://elftown.lysator.liu.se/img/drawing/60827_1169521261.jpg>
Number of votes: 1 (5%)

* e) <img0*100:http://elftown.lysator.liu.se/stuff/C%3ADocuments%20and%20SettingsWillDesktopD%26DZendelon%20-%20Northern%20orientation.jpg>
Number of votes: 2 (10%)

* f) <img0*100:http://elftown.lysator.liu.se/img/drawing/27476_1169940846.jpg>
Number of votes: 0 (0%)

* g) <img0*100:http://elftown.lysator.liu.se/img/drawing/99583_1165637041.jpg>
Number of votes: 0 (0%)

* h) <img0*100:http://elftown.lysator.liu.se/stuff/nyratar_karte_f.jpg>
Number of votes: 1 (5%)

* i) <img0*100:http://elftown.lysator.liu.se/stuff/rm11plan.png>
Number of votes: 0 (0%)

* j) <img0*100:http://elftown.lysator.liu.se/stuff/C%3ADocuments%20and%20SettingsWillDesktopD%26DTearra%20Rehm%20Web.jpg>
Number of votes: 1 (5%)

* k) <img0*100:http://elftown.lysator.liu.se/stuff/C%3ADocuments%20and%20SettingsWillDesktopD%26DQor%20Geography%20Web.jpg> <img0*100:http://elftown.lysator.liu.se/stuff/C%3ADocuments%20and%20SettingsWillDesktopD%26DQor%20Populations.jpg>
Number of votes: 0 (0%)

* l) <img0*100:http://elftown.lysator.liu.se/stuff/YnckesKaartVanEigen.jpg>
Number of votes: 3 (15%)


Username (or number or email):

Password:

2007-07-06 [xido]: POLLS ARE OPEN! You can vote multiple times on every poll except the Best of Show (Best Map)!

If you want to judge the final categories, see FMAC_Judging!

2007-07-11 [Ocean Soul]: A question - should you vote on your own entry? Because that doesn't seem to reasonable to me :/

2007-07-12 [xido]: As long as you are honestly evaluating your own work compared/contrasted to that of others and by the criteria posted, it is not disrespectful, and no one will be harassed in any way for voting as they wish.

FYI: I just uploaded the edited version of your map of Nyratar to polls 2651 and 2644 (http://elftown.lysator.liu.se/stuff/nyratar_karte_f.jpg). Everyone please reevaluate the map based on its current posting. (I will add a note to the top of the page about it)

Were there any other submissions made to [Dr.Mandarian] that I was unaware of? I can add them, if that is the case, and you have his permission to do so.
-will

2007-11-19 [Dr.Mandarian]: Hey all you cartographers! I just voted for the entries for fantasy maps above - and am once more amazed again over what high level of brilliance and calibre they are. So it was kind of a hard task for me to judge them. It is a pleasure to have such manies of high quality artworks gathered here. I once again have to thank all who participated in this! And I also want to express again, in this place, how sorry I am that the whole process of the running contest has been so unfortunately interrupted for so long, due to my absence - and kind of dragged along then. I assure you that it has got nothing to do with a lack of interest in this, to any time. I just first have been forced by personal circumstances to not be able to get online for a pretty long while. And after I returned to town, I missed energy and time enough, to dedicate myself more to the outturn of the contest procedure here.
I hope that you are not badly disappointed about that.
Still I wanted to ask you all, if you'd like to finish this contest soon, yet, after all, or if you'd maybe like me to care a bit for advertising the poll more over the next days - as for example trying to apply for a main street place for it? I don't know exactly, what [xido] planned for the further scope of the contest end, but I will in any case contact him soon and discuss with him, about the evaluation of the poll above and the finish of the whole contest. Having a winner in each category and a badge for each winner then, how I hope.

2008-03-03 [xido]: Sorry I haven't checked in much. Once I got input about my own maps, I kind of stopped watching all the time.

Let me figure out how to close the polls, in case they need to be ended, which they probably should be very soon.
-will

Show these comments on your site

Elftown - Wiki, forums, community and friendship. Sister-site to Elfwood